Same Card. Same Sale. Two Completely Different Tax Bills.
A pure collector and an active dealer sell the same card for $100,000. Their tax bills look nothing alike. Here's why.
A collector I know spent most of his adult life buying and holding. Not flipping. Not dealing. Buying things that he loved and filing them away.
He found a specific card at a show in 2001. Paid $400 for it. Put it in a top loader, filed it away, and mostly forgot it existed. Twenty-three years later, his son mentioned it. They pulled it out, looked it up, and saw a number neither of them expected.
It was worth $100,000.
He decided to sell. He had owned it for more than two decades. He knew about capital gains. He had sold stocks before, understood the rates, and budgeted mentally for somewhere around $15,000 to $20,000 in taxes.
He didn’t realize what the IRS does differently with collectibles.
He wrote a check for $28,000.
Watch me visually summarize this article if you don’t feel like reading.
The Rate That Does Not Get Announced at Card Shows
We covered the 28% collectibles rate in a recent issue. The short version: sports cards, coins, stamps, art, and most physical collectibles are not treated as standard capital gains assets. The IRS has a separate category under Section 1(h)(5), and the maximum long-term rate for that category is 28%.
Stocks top out at 20% for long-term gains. For most middle-income investors the rate is 15%. Collectibles do not get those rates.
When I first started working with serious collectors, I made the same assumption most of them do. Capital gains are capital gains. Finding out otherwise changed how I approach every planning conversation before a sale.
For the collector with the $400 card, the math was straightforward and painful. His basis was $400. His sale price was $100,000. His gain was $99,600. At 28%, his tax was $27,888.
He had nothing to offset it with. No expenses to deduct. No business entity to run costs through. Every dollar of appreciation was fully exposed.
That is the pure collector’s tax position. Hold an asset for decades, sell it, pay 28% on the gain with no mechanism to reduce the taxable number.
Now Take a Different Collector
A card dealer operates the same market. Different rules.
He buys collections, grades select pieces, and moves inventory through eBay, conventions, and private buyers. He has been doing this for six years. He has an LLC, a dedicated business bank account, and a spreadsheet tracking every card that comes in and goes out.
He acquires the same card — same market value, same sale price of $100,000.
His income from that sale is not a capital gain.
Because he is in the business of buying and selling, the IRS treats the proceeds as ordinary business income. That sounds worse on the surface. Ordinary income rates are higher. Thirty-seven percent at the top end. Most people hear “ordinary income” and assume they would pay more.
Most people would be wrong.
Ordinary income from a business comes with something the pure collector does not have.
Deductions.
The Math That Changes the Conversation
Here is how the dealer’s $100,000 sale actually looks on paper.
He paid $65,000 for the card. That is his cost of goods. His gross profit is $35,000.
Over the course of the year, he also paid:
$1,400 in grading fees across PSA and BGS submissions.
$900 in shipping, packaging, and insurance on purchases and sales.
$1,200 in show table and convention fees.
$1,800 in storage for his inventory.
$900 in business insurance on his collection.
Total deductible business expenses for the year: $6,200.
Net taxable income from that transaction: $28,800.
At a 24% federal income rate, his tax on the sale is $6,912.
The pure collector paid $28,000 on a $100,000 sale.
The dealer paid $6,912 on the same $100,000 sale.
Same card. Same market. Same gross number on the sale receipt.
The collector’s 28% rate applied to a $99,600 gain. The dealer’s 24% rate applied to a $28,800 net profit. The rate does not tell the whole story. The deductible base is what determines the actual check.
That, ladies and gentlemen, is the difference between holding a collection and running a business.
What Dealers Can Deduct
If your buying and selling activity qualifies as a trade or business under the IRS standard, here is what can come off your taxable income before the rate is applied:
Cost of goods sold. The price you paid for every card, coin, or piece you sell. Your first and largest deduction.
Grading and authentication fees. PSA, BGS, SGC, PCGS, NGC, CGC. Every submission you send out.
Shipping. Packaging, postage, and insurance in transit, both when acquiring inventory and when fulfilling sales.
Show and convention costs. Table fees, booth rental, and the direct travel costs for events where you are operating as a seller.
Storage. A dedicated unit, or the pro-rated share of space used exclusively for inventory.
Business insurance. Coverage for your inventory against loss, theft, or damage.
Professional services. Accounting, tax preparation, and any legal fees related to the business.
Business phone and internet. The portion of those costs tied to your buying and selling activity.
Photography and listing costs. Equipment or subscription services used specifically for cataloging and marketing inventory.
None of these exist for the pure collector. Every dollar of appreciation hits the full 28% rate. The dealer’s number comes down substantially before the rate is ever applied.
How the IRS Decides Which One You Are
The IRS does not take your word for it. They look at the facts of your activity.
Frequency and regularity of sales. Whether you carry on the activity in a businesslike manner. Whether you maintain separate records and a dedicated business account. How much time you spend on it. Whether you depend on the income. Whether you have had profitable years. Whether there is a genuine profit motive beyond personal enjoyment.
You do not need a brick-and-mortar store. Consistent eBay sales, regular convention presence, and maintained inventory with documented cost-of-goods tracking can support dealer classification. The IRS is looking for evidence of a trade or business, not a collector who occasionally sells when the price feels right.
The line that matters: are you doing this to generate income as a trade, or are you building a collection that you sell from when the opportunity presents itself?
If you are on the trade side, ordinary income treatment applies. So do business deductions.
If you are on the collector side, capital gains treatment applies. At 28%, with nothing to offset it.
The Self-Employment Tax Reality
There is a cost to dealer classification worth addressing directly.
Self-employment income is subject to self-employment tax in addition to federal income tax. In 2025 that rate is 15.3% on net earnings up to $168,600, then 2.9% above. Half of the SE tax is deductible, which softens it, but the number is real and needs to be accounted for.
For a dealer with high net income and no business structure, the combined effect of ordinary income rates plus self-employment tax can end up close to or above what a collector would pay at 28%.
That is why the structure conversation matters as much as the classification.
A card shop or active dealer operating as an S-corporation can pay its owner a reasonable salary and distribute remaining profit as a shareholder distribution. Only the salary portion is subject to self-employment tax. The distribution is not. The business still deducts all the same expenses. The SE tax burden comes down meaningfully.
For dealers doing serious volume, the entity structure is not an afterthought. It is where a significant amount of the planning happens.
What the Pure Collector Can Do
If you are a collector — not a dealer — and you are sitting on items with significant appreciation, a few options exist before you sell.
Installment sales. Spreading a large gain across multiple tax years keeps annual income lower and can reduce the effective rate in each year. On a $100,000 gain, splitting the recognition over three years changes the bracket math.
Donate appreciated collectibles directly to a qualified charity. Donating an item rather than selling it and donating the proceeds lets you deduct the fair market value without recognizing the capital gain.
There are limits — your deduction for tangible personal property donated to a public charity is generally capped at 30% of adjusted gross income — and you need a qualified appraisal. But for collectors who already give to charity and are holding highly appreciated items, the numbers are worth running.
Time the sale around income. The 28% collectibles rate is a ceiling, not a floor. If your ordinary income rate drops below 28% in a given year — a partial retirement year, a year when you sell a business at a loss, or any year when your taxable income is meaningfully lower — your collectibles gain may be taxed at your effective rate rather than the full 28%. A $100,000 gain in a 22% income year is taxed at 22%, not 28.
The $28,000 check was not the only possible outcome. It was the outcome of not having the conversation before he listed the card.
The Number to Take Out of This
Two people can sell the same card for the same price and write two very different checks.
One never tracked expenses, never structured a business, and held for personal enjoyment. He pays 28% on every dollar of gain.
The other ran it as a trade, tracked every cost, and structured appropriately. He pays his ordinary rate on a net number that deductions already brought down.
The rate is 28% for collectors. But the rate is only half the equation.
Grab your mug. Pull up what you are holding. And before the next big sale — whether you are a lifelong collector or a dealer running volume — make sure the person advising you knows the difference between a long-term hold and a business transaction.
The IRS already does.
Disclosures:
This blog contains general information that may not be suitable for everyone. The information contained herein should not be construed as personalized investment advice. There is no guarantee that the views and opinions expressed in this blog will come to pass. Investing in the stock market involves gains and losses and may not be suitable for all investors. Information presented herein is subject to change without notice and should not be considered as a solicitation to buy or sell any security. Revolutionary Wealth LLC does not offer legal or tax advice. Please consult the appropriate professional regarding your individual circumstance. Past performance is no guarantee of future results.
Asset protection plans should be developed and implemented well before problems arise. Due to the fraudulent transfer laws, asset transfers that occur close in proximity to the filing of a lawsuit or bankruptcy can be interpreted by the court as a fraudulent transfer. Proper structuring of these assets is imperative please seek proper legal and tax advice prior to engaging in re-titling/structuring of any assets. Please note that laws are subject to change and can have an impact on your asset protection strategy.